Two Legends, One Warning: Why Cooperman's Praise for Buffett is a Bearish Signal in Disguise
There are moments in finance that feel ceremonial, like the formal handing over of a baton. When Leon Cooperman, the billionaire investor and chair of the Omega Family Office, recently paid tribute to Warren Buffett, it had that quality. He called the 94-year-old Berkshire Hathaway chief the "gold standard in the business," a "smart" and "rational" leader who has done a "fabulous job for shareholders." With Buffett preparing to step down after 60 years at the helm, it felt like a fitting eulogy for an era of investing.
But this was not just a tribute. It was a preamble.
Cooperman delivered these remarks in the same breath as a deeply pessimistic market forecast. He stated, with the bluntness he’s known for, that he has a "very conservative outlook" for the S&P 500, predicting the index is "going nowhere." This juxtaposition of praise for a master of value investing with a warning about a speculative market is not a coincidence. It’s the entire point. Cooperman wasn't just honoring Buffett; he was using his legacy as a diagnostic tool to measure just how distorted the current environment has become.
The data, as is so often the case, provides the necessary context. The S&P 500 has not been "going nowhere." It has been on a tear, surging almost 40% since its lows this past April—to be more precise, some sub-indices have seen gains well in excess of that figure. It has breached all-time highs above 6,000 points, a milestone celebrated with the usual fanfare. Yet this ascent has pushed valuations into territory that should trigger alarms for any student of market history. The index is currently trading at a historically expensive 23 times forward earnings.
This is where Cooperman’s invocation of Buffett becomes so potent. The most famous metric bearing his name, the "Buffett Indicator" (the ratio of total U.S. stock market value to GDP), is flashing its brightest red warning signal in history. At 217%, it has surpassed the levels seen during the Dot-com Bubble and the euphoric rally of 2021. This is not a subtle indicator. It suggests the paper value of corporate America has become profoundly detached from the real-world economy it supposedly represents.
The Anatomy of a Late-Stage Warning
The Anatomy of a Late-Innings Market
Cooperman’s diagnosis is that we are in the "late innings of a bull market." This is the phase Buffett himself has warned about, where logic gives way to momentum and the disciplined search for value is replaced by a frantic chase for returns. The behavior Cooperman observes maps directly onto this historical pattern. He points to the speculative fervor around artificial intelligence, where valuations on some companies have become, in his words, "ridiculously high."
I've looked at market cycles for two decades, and this is where the data gets genuinely uncomfortable. The dissonance between the celebratory headlines and the underlying valuation metrics is as wide as I've ever seen it. The common argument is that "this time is different" due to the transformative potential of AI. But this requires a methodological critique of the numbers being used. How, precisely, are we modeling the forward earnings for a technology whose broad monetization path remains highly speculative? The ‘E’ in the P/E ratio for many of these market darlings is based more on a compelling narrative than on audited, predictable cash flow. When the denominator of your key valuation metric is a guess, the entire ratio becomes an exercise in sentiment, not analysis.
Cooperman, a man who converted his own hedge fund, Omega Advisors, into a family office in 2018, is now managing his own capital. This perspective matters. His focus is on capital preservation as much as growth, a discipline that gets lost in a momentum-driven frenzy. His prescription is therefore logical: stop betting on the market as a whole and start identifying specific, undervalued stocks. It’s a classic, bottom-up approach that stands in stark contrast to the passive, index-driven strategy that has dominated the last decade.
The macro environment he outlines supports this caution. A combination of slow growth and stubbornly high inflation seems probable, exacerbated by geopolitical risks from overseas conflicts and the persistent threat of tariffs. In such an environment, the broad market indices can be held hostage by a few overvalued mega-cap stocks, masking weakness in the underlying majority.
Yet, there is a crucial nuance in Cooperman's position that many will miss. He stated, "Stocks are less risky than bonds at these levels." This seems contradictory, but it’s a perfectly rational statement for an analyst concerned about inflation. Elevated inflation is a direct assault on the real returns of fixed-income instruments. A bond yielding 4% in a 3.5% inflation environment offers a negligible real return, with no potential for capital appreciation. An undervalued company with pricing power, however, can protect its margins and grow its intrinsic value, offering a shield against the very inflation that erodes a bond's worth. This isn’t a bullish call on the market; it’s a bearish call on cash and fixed income. It’s a flight to tangible value, not a flight to safety.
Ultimately, the tribute to Buffett serves as the analytical anchor. For 60 years, Buffett built an empire on a simple, repeatable process: identify excellent businesses, assess their intrinsic value, and buy them at a rational price. Cooperman, who has been married to the same woman for 61 years, understands the power of long-term, rational commitment. By holding up Buffett as the "gold standard," he is implicitly stating that the market is currently operating on a counterfeit standard, one backed by momentum and narrative rather than by cash flow and value. The praise is a lament for a discipline that appears to be in scarce supply.
The Valuation Anomaly ###
The core discrepancy is this: the market is celebrating the retirement of a man whose entire investment philosophy serves as a direct condemnation of its current behavior. Cooperman’s tribute wasn't a nostalgic farewell. It was a data-driven warning, using the ultimate benchmark of rational investing to highlight a market that has become profoundly irrational. The numbers suggest an environment where risk is mispriced on a historic scale, and the greatest tribute one could pay to Warren Buffett right now is to listen to that warning.
Reference article source：
